"Gobbet" Exercise Guidelines
A "gobbet" answer is a concise analytical comment on a short extract from
a textual documentary source, or - in the case of this Detailed Study - a
poster image. It is an exercise in de-construction, aimed at extracting
the maximum historical understanding from the image in question. The
answer should be brief (400-500 words) and sharply focussed on the issues
arising from the source.
These guidelines are not prescriptive, but are offered as an aid in
developing an effective "gobbet" answer technique. In view of the fact
that the selected posters vary considerably in style and content, not all
the points referred to below will be relevent in every case.
Preparation:
- Ensure that you fully understand the purpose of the poster
and thoroughly research the issues which it addresses in the available
literature.
Writing the "gobbet" answer:
- Although not mandatory, maintaining a tight, three-part, paragraph
structure for your answer will aid concentration on the key elements
required.
- 1. Context (approximately 20% of the answer)
- Place the poster concerned into the context of social, political
and military developments in wartime Britain. Explain the purpose of the
poster - why was it issued? when? who published it? where was it
displayed? at whom was the message aimed? Comment also on the style and
tone of the poster and on any interesting features of graphic design.
- 2. Analysis (approximately 60% of the answer)
- Analyse in turn both the content and the presentation of the
poster. Identify any individuals or events depicted and explain their
significance in wartime Britain. Comment on the theme of the poster,
explaining its significance at the time. Analyse also any underlying
implications contained in the text or the image. What does the poster
reveal about the social or political attitudes of these responsible for
the design? Comment also on the psychological approach to the subject
matter. (For example - is humour being used, and why?) Pay attention to
the artistic style employed and comment on the authenticity of the image.
Look for fine nuances in the illustration and compare the contents with
that of other related posters.
- 3. Evaluation (approximately 20% of the
answer)
- Evaluate the historical significance of the poster, relating it to
the general theme of the Detailed Study. What does it reveal about
conditions in wartime Britain? Are the issues raised by the poster typical
or exceptional? Does it give rise to any particular problems for the
historian? Comment also on the likely effectiveness of the poster,
particularly in terms of its presentational attributes.
Remember:
- You are not required to describe the poster nor to write a
short essay round the subject concerned.
- Do not exceed the word limit. Choose your words with maximum precision
and economy of space in mind.
- Above all, think critically!